Canned Pumpkin Does Not Actually Contain Any Pumpkin At All

Fall is the season everyone loves. It's the crisp air, the changing leaves, and the golden sunlight that reinvigorate us after a hot summer. And it's also the time of year when pumpkins take over, well, everything.

It's not just in gardens and as jack o'lanterns. We're talking pumpkin cheesecake, pumpkin bread, pumpkin muffins, and pumpkin spice lattes, all full of flavor and some surprising health benefits, too. And, of course, there's the one most people are familiar with: pumpkin pie.

And unless you happen to be hollowing out a pumpkin, the easiest way to make a pumpkin pie is with canned pumpkin, most of which comes pre-spiced. Easy and convenient.

Only…it's not actually pumpkin.

We know. It's shocking. But it's true. Most of the canned pumpkin puree sold in supermarkets doesn't have a lick of pumpkin in it, even though there's a bright orange pumpkin right on the label. But more on that later.

So what's in your pumpkin pie? Read on to find out! And don't worry, this information won't ruin your fall.

[H/T: Hot Moms Club, Extra Crispy]

23625918_1504614172.8288_funddescription.jpg
Wikimedia Commons

You've probably used a can of pumpkin puree like this at least once in your life to make a fall-time treat like pumpkin pie.

23625918_1504614433.6732_funddescription.jpg
Flickr / Laura

The canned puree is a practical option for many people when they feel like baking, but either don't have a pumpkin on hand, or just don't feel like scooping one out to get the pumpkin guts used to make pies, breads, and all kinds of other treats.

Except…it's not pumpkin.

gofundme.jpg
Flickr / Kim

The revelation is a little shocking. In North America especially, pumpkins and fall are practically synonymous. So if you're not having pumpkin, what are you having? And why isn't it pumpkin?

gofundme-1.jpg
Wikimedia Commons

To answer those questions, first you'll need a little background on pumpkins.

This pumpkin is one of many varieties, and it's called the Curcubita pepo. Its round shape and bright color make it ideal for carving, and it's what everyone thinks of when they think "pumpkin."

gofundme-2.jpg
Wikimedia Commons

The problem with Curcubita pepo, though, is that they're all show. They're not terribly flavorful.

If you've ever made a pie with one of these pumpkins, you might have noticed that you need a lot of sugar and spices to get a strong flavor.

So when you use the canned stuff, what are you eating?

toilet-twinning.png
Wikimedia Commons

Don't worry, nothing terrible at all!

You're actually eating these guys, cousins of the Curcubita pepo. 

Meet Curcubita moschata. You probably know this other fall staple as a butternut squash.

And if you live in Australia, you already call this a pumpkin anyway.

Screen-Shot-2017-09-06-at-9.37.49-AM.png
Flickr / Forest and Kim Starr

They're not as pretty as their orange cousins, nor is their thin rind ideal for jack o'lantern carving, but they're much more flavorful.

And if you're wondering why the FDA allows butternut squash to be paraded around under a pumpkin label, it's because the two squash are so closely related and so similar that the FDA doesn't bother differentiating them.

So a squash is a pumpkin is a squash.

Screen-Shot-2017-09-06-at-9.39.02-AM.png
Flickr

So, happily, that means that you can go ahead and use the canned stuff — and still call it pumpkin pie!

And really, at the end of it all, you still have pie, and isn't that really what counts?

SHARE this shocking autumn secret with your pumpkin-obsessed friends, and then go eat some pie. You deserve it.