Many were surprised when Mayim Bialik announced that she would no longer host Jeopardy! On December 15, 2023, she shared the announcement on Instagram, writing, "Sony has informed me that I will no longer be hosting the syndicated version of Jeopardy!" The post made many suspect that Mayim was fired, though a statement from Jeopardy! paints a confusingly different picture.
On the same day, a statement posted on the Jeopardy! Instagram account noted, "Mayim Bialik has announced she will no longer be hosting the syndicated version of Jeopardy!"
The statement from Jeopardy! makes it sound like the decision was Mayim's, while Mayim's statement suggests otherwise. But the next part of Jeopardy!'s statement makes it even less clear. "We made the decision to have one host for the syndicated show next season to maintain continuity for our viewers," the statement continued.
The statement went on to say that Ken Jennings, Mayim's former cohost, would be the only host moving forward. To make matters even stranger, Ken revealed that even he was surprised when he learned about Mayim's departure.
“It took me off guard, because I loved working with my Mayim and I’m going to miss her. I can’t speak to her decision-making process or her opinions about it," Ken said in an interview with The Hollywood Reporter.
More from LittleThings: Elon Musk Is Sued By Former Employee Who Did Not Receive Promised Bonuses In 2022
So what's the real reason that Mayim will no longer be a host? Some were quick to blame politics. Mayim is Jewish and has been vocal about her support for Israel. In a video shared on Instagram, she and Israeli actor Noa Tishby discussed Hamas, mimicking Jeopardy! while doing so. The video's caption also referred Jeopardy! "The free world is in jeopardy, but this time it’s not a game. Here are the facts. Let’s face reality," they said in the caption.
The reason Sony might've had an issue with this, according to journalist Claire McNear, who investigated the reason for Mayim's departure in a piece for The Ringer, is because Jeopardy! has branded itself as being neutral and apolitical. The Instagram video is just on example of many times in which Mayim shared her opinions online, which The New York Times also highlighted in 2021 in a piece titled, "Mayim Bialik Wants the ‘Jeopardy!’ Job. Is She ‘Neutral’ Enough?"
Now, some suspect that the answer to that question is a definitive "no." In 2014, Mayim wrote a blog titled, "Why I Donated Money to Send Bulletproof Vests to the IDF." She was previously accused of victim blaming and being anti-vaccine because of content she wrote, though she later clarified her positions on both issues. She also speaks openly about mental health via her own podcast.
Several sources also pointed to the fact that Mayim was absent from the show during the last week of the season when she supported the Writers Guild of America strike. Though all the clues used were written before the writers went on strike, many were critical of Jeopardy! for moving forward and of Ken Jennings for filling in for Mayim.
Sony was reportedly not happy with Mayim's decision at the time, according to Puck News. Journalist Matthew Belloni alleges that although the strike might not be the only reason for Mayim's departure, her "actions during the strike were at least a contributing factor."
But TMZ reported that sources say this is not exactly what happened. Instead, Mayim's temporary absence allegedly "showed Sony executives they didn’t need two hosts for the quiz show, and that’s why they moved on," according to the outlet.
Sources told TMZ that the strike itself was not the issue — rather, it brought other issues to light. According to TMZ, “bosses at Sony weren’t mad when Mayim refused to work during this year’s strike, but her absence opened execs’ eyes about their dual host system."
Claire McNear also mentioned another reason Mayim was maybe not the best cultural fit for the show: she didn't grow up watching it. Though Mayim has many fans who are sad to see her leave the show, some Jeopardy! viewers were critical of her from the beginning. Mayim and Ken began cohosting temporarily in 2021 and became the permanent hosts in 2022. Some criticized Mayim because she wasn't as familiar with the show. Ken, in contrast, is a former contestant and a big fan.
"I’m just a fan of Jeopardy! and I’m always delighted to host when they call upon me," Ken shared with The Hollywood Reporter when speaking about the recent announcement.
In her announcement post, Mayim also said that she is "deeply grateful for the opportunity to have been a part of the Jeopardy! family." The statement from Jeopardy! also expressed gratitude for "all of Mayim's contributions." "We hope to continue to work with her on primetime specials," the statement said.
